
A few weeks ago we had a big backyard party to celebrate both my boyfriend’s birthday as well as his sister’s (they are one day and some years apart).
After some back and forth, I decided to make a
fudgy sour cream chocolate cake frosted with
pillowy swiss meringue. The final result was an incredible, fork scraping the plate cake. It was wonderfully textured, softly mouth-filling, and subtle in the best way, and reminded me of my favorite childhood snack cake: the Suzy Q.
The cake recipe comes from the wonderful book
How to Make an American Layer Cake from
The Cook’s Illustrated Library (It’s out of print, but you can pick up a copy for a few dollars on
Amazon).
Sour Cream-Fudge Layer CakeGrease and flour
two 9” round cake pans (I used butter, they recommend shortening) and turn the
oven to 350.
In a small bowl, mix
1 cup nonalkalinized cocoa powder with
2 tsp. instant espresso. Stir in
1 cup of boiling water. Mix until smooth and let cool to room temperature, then stir in
2 tsp. vanilla and
½ cup sour cream.
In another bowl,
whisk 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour with
3/4 tsp. baking soda and
1/2 tsp. salt. Set aside.
Cream
2 sticks of unsalted, room temperature butter with
1 3/4 cups white sugar, beating until very fluffy and almost white in color (3-5
minutes). Add
the first of 2 large room-temperature eggs, beat for one full minute, then add the other egg and beat for an additional minute.
With mixer on low, alternate adding the drys with the cocoa-based blend in three parts. Mix until batter takes on a lovely satin-like quality, then pour into your prepared pans and
bake for 23 to 30 minutes or until your cake test comes back clean or with just a few crumbs.
Let cool on rack for 10 minutes, then remove the layers from the pans and let cool
un-armoured.
The Swiss Meringue I used was such a basic recipe that I can not even recall where I found it. That said, any good baking book should have a recipe for this wonderfully versatile frosting. I slathered some between the two layers, then covered the whole lot with a thick, shiny white coat...

and the candles...

I wish I had a photo of the lit cake or a slice to leave you with, but circumstances prevented those shots from happening. I do have one photo which strikes me as an ocean of icing, so I'll say goodbye with a trip to a sugary sea...